3/24/2011

What is a Short Circuit and or Relay Coordination Study?

Article by: cpswitchgear.com

Why specify a short circuit and relay study?

Does your facility use trip units (relays) on circuit breakers? Have the settings been adjusted by one of the plant electricians so nuisance trips on the breaker was stopped? Do you know what the existing device settings are, and are they correct? Too many facilities are being protected by trip units that are not set for the correct operation of the circuit breaker. The main breaker to the switchgear may be tripping before the load breaker that supply’s a motor trips. The most common reason for the incorrect circuit breaker coordination tripping sequence is because the relays are not set as designed for the switchgear.

What is the definition of a short circuit and or relay coordination study?
To define a short circuit and or relay coordination study in simple terms, coordination means that downstream devices (breakers) should trip before upstream breakers. This keeps the fault at or near the equipment that causes the inrush of current to occur. Short Circuit and Coordination Study’s are designed not only to protect the equipment, but to save lives. The correct interrupting rating is critical for safe, economical, and efficient operation of any electrical distribution system. If you have seen an electrical fault where current is greater than the interrupting rating of the protective apparatus, the cost, and consequences can be serious. Personnel injury, damaged equipment and downtime are all too common when the relay coordination is not set to correctly open circuits when called upon. Coordination Studies isolate the first protective device inline to the fault.

Below is the beginning of a relay coordination study Carolina Precision Switchgear provided for one of our customers.


Information used was provided via a power riser diagram E0.2 and copy of hand written notes of existing settings and breaker trip unit sizes. Where information was lacking it is note below.

Cable information was provided or derived from the power riser diagram.

The TE1L1 and TE1L2 transformers are protected at 175% for Long Time and Instantaneous set 10 times the full load amps. The Short Time is set to allow inrush without nuisance tripping. Both breakers also coordinate with DB-1.

This also applies to the transformers feed from breakers E1L3 and E1L4.
E1HE1, E1HL, UPS, E1HM1, E1HM2, UPS2, and UPS BYPASS breakers are set to protect the cable and coordinate with DB-1.

The DB-1 breaker is set to coordinate with all the above breakers and is set slightly below the Main breaker MSB-2

The MSB-2 breaker is set to coordinate with all sub-feed breakers and protect the cable feeding the DB-1 Switchboard.

You have a full investment in your equipment, so why use it to its full and capable potential?

Don't wait for an outage to find out there's a problem.

Contact Carolina Precision Switchgear today at www.cpswitchgear or phone 704-596-4242 to let us help you with your nuisance trips, and help fully protect your valuable personnel and equipment.

1 comment:

  1. Your Blog shares a valuable information about Short circuit analysis. It is very helpfull to detect the problems in short circuits.You warn the workers based on the international standards for personal protective equipment about Safety measurements in electrical hazards. To determine the short circuit currents is one of the most important aspects of designing power distribution systems. The effects of short circuits must be considered in selecting circuit protecting devices, Electrical equipment, Carrying out Arc Flash Analysis. The short circuit calculator is used to satisfy the need for a convenient, Comprehensive method of calculating fault currents. It is intended to Looped and radial low and medium voltage circuits. The calculator allows to Easily and Quickly obtain accurate potential short circuit currents at each node in a power distribution system.we are one of the top most Electrical hazard safety assessment consultants in the world.we provide services like Arc Flash Analysis, Short Circuit Analysis, Harmonic analysis, Relay coordination, etc, ....If you have any queries, Click on Short Circuit Analysis <|a>

    ReplyDelete